Visiting Šibenik in November 2011, I had hoped to
follow in the footsteps of the 19th century English Egyptologist, J. Gardner
Wilkinson, on a journey up the river Krka to the Visovac and Krka monasteries. Alas,
how times had changed since his visit more than 150 years earlier. Gardner Wilkinson
travelled by boat, and was treated as an honoured guest at the Franciscan
friary at Visovac. Today, the area around the Krka is a national park,
preserved and developed for tourism. Travel up and down the river depends on
the timetable of tourist boats, and in November, out of the tourist season,
they were not running.
The autumn was nonetheless a wonderful time to visit
the falls at Skradinski Buk, reachable by bus from Šibenik, and a short walk
down to the river. With very few tourists, I could stroll peacefully around the
walkways, enjoying the spectacular cascades, framed by the autumnal colours of
the surrounding trees. But I wanted to make the full trip, and to do it by
boat.
So back again in the spring, this time I took the boat
from the park entrance at the little town of Skradin, up to the falls at
Skradinski Buk. The English architect, T.G. Jackson, made this journey in the
1880s. He described passing through a gorge “if possible still more sterile and
white than any we had seen.” It is true that Dalmatia is notable for its barren
landscape of bleached limestone mountains, and expanses of scrubby little
bushes. Behind the exquisite towns of the coast, built from the same limestone
rock, it is a hard, hot, unforgiving land. But the gorge to which Jackson
referred is no longer sterile. The hills on either side are a mass of green
trees, the river banks trimmed with reed beds, an occasional swan gliding among
them. I had more than once heard Dalmatians complain that their region had been
stripped of its trees during centuries of Venetian rule, the timber used for
the Republic’s ships and the piles that formed the foundations of the city’s
buildings, an early example of human-induced environmental degradation. If this
were so, perhaps the forests along the banks of the Krka had had time to
recover since the end of Venetian exploitation.
Skradinski Buk had a heavier flow of water than the
previous autumn, the normal spring swell. This was despite the drought I had
been told was afflicting much of Croatia. Another 19th century visitor to the
falls was the Emperor Franz Josef, in 1875. His visit is commemorated by a notice
next to a viewing point built out over the river by local people for the
Emperor to view the falls. According to the notice, people thronged the
surrounding hills, and greeted the Emperor by shooting their pistols in the
air, with shouts of “Živio” – “Long life”!
Visovac Franciscan Friary
I took the tourist boat up to Visovac. The friary, on
an island in the middle of the river, surrounded by cypress trees, is an
idyllic scene. Unlike in Gardner Wilkinson’s day, when a foreign visitor was
rare and feted, nowadays the friars generally stay out of the way of the
tourists and pilgrims that pour over the island. Founded in the 14th century as
an Augustinian monastery, the monks fled the encroaching Turks. In the 15th
century, Franciscans moved in from Bosnia, where the order was specially
favoured by the Ottoman rulers, and licensed by them to minister to their
Catholic subjects.
Today, the friary serves as a seminary, housing three
friars and nine seminarians at the time of my visit. During the 1990s conflict,
the friary was close to the front line. Our guide told us that shells fell in
the surrounding area, and even on the friary itself, and that the seminarians
were removed to a safer place, on the coast.
Housed in the friary is a small museum. The walls of
one room are covered with photographs of Catholic churches damaged and ruined
during the war. The guide gave us his potted history of the war: in 1991 the
Serbs attacked Slovenia and then Croatia; in 1992 they attacked Bosnia; and
half of Bosnia is still occupied by the Serbs. It is a partial description. The
walls contain no pictures of ruined Orthodox churches or mosques. There is
nothing about the Serbs from the Dalmatian hinterland driven out in 1995, their
homes destroyed or occupied by Croats to prevent them from ever returning. Nor
about the hundreds of Serb civilians murdered in the aftermath of the Croat
reconquest of Serb-controlled territory. The mention of Serb ‘occupation’ of
half of Bosnia omits reference to Croatia’s participation in the attempted
carve-up of Bosnia with the Serbs, in which some Herzegovinian Franciscans were
implicated. Nothing about the wanton destruction of the old town of Stolac in
southern Herzegovina, its Muslim population expelled, the town wrecked, not in
any fighting, for there was none in Stolac, but in an attempt by its wartime
Croat occupiers to expunge all evidence of its Ottoman, oriental past, and of
its Muslim population.
This is so typical of Catholic Croats, as well as of
Orthodox Serbs, all of their focus on the sufferings of their own people, the
damage to their churches, the Golgotha of their nation, and no acknowledgement
of the sufferings, the injustices against others. In all their Christian
charity, there is no time or space for others.
Yet the Visovac museum also contains an exhibit which
hints at a time when relations among Catholics and Orthodox in the Dalmatian
hinterland were not as fraught as they became in the 20th century. The exhibit
in question is the sword of Vuk Mandušić, a local 17th century hero who fought
against the Turks. Mandušić is one of the characters in the epic poem, The
Mountain Wreath, by the Montenegrin poet and Prince-Bishop, Petar Petrušić
Njegoš, and is a favourite of Serb epic poetry. Mandušić was Orthodox, which in
21st century Dalmatia would make him a Serb. Indeed, today his legacy is
celebrated by wild-eyed Serb nationalist guslar players, wailing out their
violent diatribes accompanied by the tuneless one-string instrument. Yet in the
17th century he could be a hero to Catholics and Orthodox believers alike. Was
he a Serb or a Croat hero? In his day the question would have been irrelevant.
For the more sophisticated population of the coast, he would have been a Vlach,
or Morlach, as most of the population of the wild interior were identified. Yet
the sword, and the memory, of this Orthodox slayer of Turks has been preserved
in a Catholic friary.
Gardner Wilkinson continued his journey by boat up the
Krka. From Visovac, boats could only go as far as the Roški slap waterfalls,
and in order for him to continue from there it was necessary to send ahead to
the Orthodox monastery of Michael the Archangel to ask them to send a boat to
the other side of the falls. According to Gardner Wilkinson’s account, this
presented the Visovac friars with a dilemma. They were not in the habit of
communicating with the Orthodox monastery, and were concerned not to open
themselves to the possibility of an affront. But one of the friars recalled
that the ‘Greeks’ had been very civil on a past occasion, and that a letter to
them might initiate friendly relations. So Gardner Wilkinson was able to
proceed on his journey.
He found the Orthodox monks to be as hospitable as the
Franciscans, and described the archimandrite as having the ‘manners of a
gentleman educated in Europe.’ He noted that, whereas in the Catholic religious
houses there were pictures of the Austrian emperor, the pope etc., in the
Orthodox monastery it was the Russian emperor who adorned the walls. As the
Ottoman Empire retreated, Austria set itself up as the protector of the
Catholics of the Balkans, whereas Russia played the same role for the Orthodox.
Thus political and national identities were drawn on religious lines, between
Serbs and Croats, and wider conflicts between the empires of Europe imprinted
themselves on the Balkan region.
For the modern traveller there was no possibility of
staying at either monastery, as Gardner Wilkinson had done. And the timetable
of the tourist boats did not permit a continuation by boat up to the Orthodox
monastery. So I took the bus from Šibenik to Knin, and from there travelled by
train to the little town of Kistanje, a couple of miles walk from the monastery.
A forlorn railway station, near Kistanje
The journey to Kistanje was a sad affair. Seventeen
years after the war, and the flight or expulsion of most of the Serbs of the
region, it had still not recovered. When I first travelled through the Knin
region, not long after the end of the conflict, it was a desolate landscape,
scarred with ruined houses, burnt out by people determined to empty the
territory of Serbs forever. Knin itself had to some extent come back to life,
its departed Serbs partially replaced by incoming Bosnian Croats. An American
international official who had worked in Knin for the UN during the war, and
returned there a few years later with the Organisation for Security and
Cooperation in Europe, said the experience of returning reminded her of the
film “Invasion of the Body Snatchers”. The town was the same, but the people
were different. But the surrounding villages have been left half-empty, bereft,
some elderly Serbs returning to live out their last days on their own land, but
few young. Railway stations along the line to Kistanje were gutted, fallen
down, still in use – trains still stopped there, but apparently not worth
repairing.
Kistanje had seen some redevelopment. After the
conflict, the Croatian authorities settled Croats from Janjevo, in Kosovo, in
Kistanje, occupying Serb-owned houses. In an effort to promote Serb return, the
US embassy in the late 1990s financed the building of new homes for some of the
Janjevo Croats, in order to free up Serb-owned homes for returnees. There has
also been some renovation of civic buildings in the town centre.
A brash new Catholic Church with a tall tower has been
built in this formerly almost entirely Serb town. The tower reminded me of the
tall tower on a new Catholic church in Mostar, close to the former frontline
between Bosniac east and Croat west. Such a tower in an ethnically divided land
makes a statement; that this town is Croat. Round the corner from the church in
Kistanje sits an older, more serene Orthodox church. Some Serbs have returned,
although there is precious little employment for them. And ruined buildings in
the very centre of the town are testimony to the fact that the place is
essentially still a wreck.
The walk to the monastery was tougher than I had
expected. It was only the beginning of May, but the temperature was already
baking hot, and the sparse, scrubby little bushes offered practically no
protection against the sun. But as the road descends towards the Krka, the
river appears, snaking between the tree-covered hills, and then the monastery,
sitting close to the bank of the river on one side, and a large, green pond on
another. It is an idyllic setting. The monastery dates to the 14th Century,
when it was endowed by Jelena, sister of the Serbian Emperor Stefan Dušan, who
was married to a local nobleman.
Orthodox Monastery of Michael the Archangel, Krka
The monastery was in the Serb-held para-state of
Krajina during the recent conflict. Following Operation Storm, by which Croatia
reclaimed the Serb-controlled territory and drove out most of its Serb
inhabitants, the monastery was ransacked. Important documents were lost, one of
the monks told me. There has since been considerable renovation, mainly
financed by the Serb diaspora, the monk told me, with contributions also from
the Serbian government and, he somewhat grudgingly acknowledged, from the
Croatian government. It is now in a fine state, although some renovation work
remains to be undertaken. It also houses a school. The monk spoke sadly of the
near-empty villages in the surrounding area, the burned houses, the lack of
young people.
I mentioned the visit Gardner Wilkinson had made 150
years before. Among the graves in a little graveyard just outside the monastery
walls were some from the decades after Gardner Wilkinson’s visit. I stood in
front of one of them, wondering whether this was the archimandrite Gardner
Wilkinson had met. I told how the Franciscans at Visovac and the Orthodox monks
had cooperated to help Gardner Wilkinson on his journey, and noted the
apparently friendly relations that had existed between the two religious houses
at that time. The monk replied that up until the Second World War relations had
indeed been ‘correct’. But since then they had been harmed by the genocide
committed during that war against the Serb people under the Croatian fascist
Ustaša regime, in which, he asserted, some Catholic priests had participated.
They had never apologised, and they had never acknowledged what had happened,
he said.
A young pupil from the monastery school interjected
that every Serb in that region had relatives who had been killed during the Second
World War. He claimed that one million had been murdered at the Ustaša death
camp at Jasenovac. My heart sank as I listened to this. While the depredations
of the murderous Ustaša were a fact, the massively inflated numbers that so
many Serbs persist in claiming only detract from their case and alienate those
Croats who would naturally be inclined to sympathise. The more usual claim had
been 700,000, but why not round it up to a cool million, after all? The number
of the dead at Jasenovac has been a matter of severe contention for years.
Croatia’s late President, Franjo Tudjman, had been obsessed with the issue, and
research he promoted suggested a figure closer to 50-60,000, including
thousands of Romas, Jews and anti-Ustaša Croats. Tudjman’s insensitivity to the
traumas of the Serbs in World War II, his rehabilitation of some Ustaša fellow
travellers, and his generally fierce Croatian nationalism had a baleful
influence in the conflict of the early 1990s, driving frightened Serbs into the
hands of Milošević and his propagandists. But the numbers he came up with are
almost certainly closer to the reality, and they constitute a damning enough
indictment of the Ustaša regime.
My visits to the two monasteries on the Krka, both of
them beautiful, historic institutions, brought home once again how miserably
both the Catholic and Orthodox churches in this region, with honourable
individual exceptions, have failed in their Christian mission. Both obsessed
with their own nation’s rights and their own nation’s sufferings, wilfully
blind to the pains of others, they have perverted and distorted the faith they
both profess. It is surely a shame and a disgrace that these followers of
Christ are the last people to look to in hope of reconciliation. Rather, they
have persistently been at the forefront of the most uncompromisingly
nationalist elements in their respective nations. They have been heralds of
conflict and intolerance. The Balkans would have been better off without them.